Comments
Comment guidelines
A few simple rules to keep the conversations on narnia.guide a pleasure to read.
The spirit of the comments
Comments are here to share a reading, a memory, a question or a detail about Narnia and C.S. Lewis. Other readers read them, some of them very young: write as you would speak to someone you respect.
What is welcome
- Opinions on the books, the films and the articles, critical ones included.
- Questions, even the simplest.
- Corrections: if you point out a mistake, give your source (book, chapter, page).
- Replies to other readers, on the substance and with courtesy.
What is not published
- Insults, personal attacks, hateful or discriminatory remarks.
- Advertising and repeated messages. Links are not accepted in comments.
- Plot revelations without a warning: start with "Spoiler alert".
- Personal data (address, phone number, e-mail), yours or anyone else's.
- Texts copied without their source, and content that does not respect copyright.
- Messages unrelated to the page.
Moderation
Every comment is read before it is published. The site is run by a volunteer, so this can take a few days. We do not publish comments that break these guidelines, and we may later remove a comment that is already online.
Replies from the team are signed "Professor Kirke".
What we ask you for
A pseudonym, shown with your comment, and an e-mail address, which is never shown. A comment is at most 2000 characters long. You can reply to another comment.
To find out what happens to this information, read the Data protection page.
Correcting or removing your comment
A comment cannot be edited once it is sent. To have it corrected or removed, write to us from the Contact page, giving the page and the date of the comment.
Last updated: 17 November 2026.